Namak Siki Bina Paani Ki Roti Recipe: The Forgotten Salt-Baked Bread From Rajasthan

Bina pani ki roti is a lost recipe that comes from Sambhar in Rajasthan. The local bread doubles up into a dessert and is cooked on heated salt granules.

Contributed By

Aanchal Poddar

June 6, 2025

Daal baati churma, ker sangri, laal maas, and lehsun ki chutney… these are some dishes that will cross your mind when you think about Rajasthani cuisine. However, the region’s peculiarly dry climate and arid terrain have led to the creation of many dishes that have been lost to time but remain deeply embedded in its culinary canon. One such forgotten dish is namak siki or bina paani ki roti. 

I tried this local bread, which doubles as a dessert and is baked on a salt bed without using water, during my stay at the very new and lavish Anantara Jewel Bagh, Jaipur. 

Executive chef Sunil Jajoria shared a bit about its history and the conditions under which this ingenious way of making bread developed—“The recipe comes from Sambhar in Rajasthan. The larger salt granules from the Salt Lake in Sambhar were sold off and the dust the was left behind was used to create these beds,” he said. 

Coupled with the traditional method of baking on a salt bed, the dough of the roti is kneaded using pure ghee, a technique specific to the state’s dry climate. While the recipe is currently almost absent from Rajasthan’s kitchens, historically, it was prepared for souvenir rituals, particularly when daughters would travel to their in-laws’ homes after marriage. At other times, it was also used as a mid-travel snack. 

“Some stories tell that people would tuck in funny or wishing messages inside the bread to add a personal touch and an element of surprise,” said Jajoria. Maybe we had something similar to fortune cookies much before the world had it. 

The baking process involves placing the dough on a salt bed that provides constant heat and allows the bread to bake with minimal colour. It takes almost two hours to heat the salt and 10-12 minutes to bake the roti to perfection. 

Unlike most breads that become mouldy in a matter of a few days, this bread-cum-dessert boasted a longer shelf life because of the ghee-infused dough. “We now live in changed times. Technological developments like the oven and a lack of time in this fast-paced world have led this dish to disappear,” added Jajoria.

If you’re keen to try this unique bread, follow Chef Jajoria’s recipe to bake the bina paani ki roti at home. 

Quick Info
Prep Time 20 min
Cook Time 40 min
Total Time 60 min
Servings 5
Difficulty hard
Ingredients
  • Freshly crushed refined flour or wheat flour - 2 cup
  • Pure ghee (some extra for greasing) - 0.5 cup
  • Powdered sugar or boora with cardamom (optional for a slightly sweet flavour) - 2 tbsp
  • Salt - 0.5 tsp
Instructions
Step-1
Prepare the Dough:
Step-2
In a large mixing bowl, combine the flour, ghee, and powdered sugar (boora- optional for sweetness).
Step-3
Mix well using your fingers until the ghee fully mixes into the flour, giving the dough a crumbly texture.
Step-4
If you prefer a slightly sweet flavor, you can also add cardamom powder to the dough for an extra fragrance.
Step-5
Gradually add a little water to form a soft dough. The dough should be firm and slightly crumbly in texture.
Step-6
Shape the Roti:
Step-7
Grease your palms with a little ghee and take small portions of the dough.
Step-8
Roll each portion into a small ball and gently flatten it into a round shape, about 1/2 inch thick. The dough might crack at the edges, which is normal due to its crumbly nature.
Step-9
Since this roti is fragile, handle it with care while shaping.
Step-10
Prepare the Salt Bed:
Step-11
You will also need coarse salt granules for this recipe. They will be used to create a salt bed for baking the roti.
Step-12
If using a Sambhar salt bed, spread a layer of coarse salt granules on a large flat surface (like a metal baking tray, or traditional salt bed if available). Heat the salt bed to a moderate temperature.
Step-13
Cook the roti:
Step-14
Gently place the shaped roti on a brass plate. Place the plate on the heated salt bed.
Step-15
To ensure even cooking, pierce the roti with a toothpick to allow the heat to penetrate, and optionally, add a few saffron water dots on top for an added flavor and fragrance.
Step-16
Cover it with a lid to trap the heat and bake the roti for 10 to 12 minutes.
Step-17
The roti should bake slowly, with a light golden color but minimal browning.
Step-18
Notes:
Step-19
Ensure that no water but only ghee is used in the preparation of the roti’s dough.
Recipe
Prep Time 20 min
Cook Time 40 min
Total Time 60 min
Servings 5
Difficulty hard
Ingredients
  • Freshly crushed refined flour or wheat flour - 2 cup
  • Pure ghee (some extra for greasing) - 0.5 cup
  • Powdered sugar or boora with cardamom (optional for a slightly sweet flavour) - 2 tbsp
  • Salt - 0.5 tsp
Instructions
Step-1
Prepare the Dough:
Step-2
In a large mixing bowl, combine the flour, ghee, and powdered sugar (boora- optional for sweetness).
Step-3
Mix well using your fingers until the ghee fully mixes into the flour, giving the dough a crumbly texture.
Step-4
If you prefer a slightly sweet flavor, you can also add cardamom powder to the dough for an extra fragrance.
Step-5
Gradually add a little water to form a soft dough. The dough should be firm and slightly crumbly in texture.
Step-6
Shape the Roti:
Step-7
Grease your palms with a little ghee and take small portions of the dough.
Step-8
Roll each portion into a small ball and gently flatten it into a round shape, about 1/2 inch thick. The dough might crack at the edges, which is normal due to its crumbly nature.
Step-9
Since this roti is fragile, handle it with care while shaping.
Step-10
Prepare the Salt Bed:
Step-11
You will also need coarse salt granules for this recipe. They will be used to create a salt bed for baking the roti.
Step-12
If using a Sambhar salt bed, spread a layer of coarse salt granules on a large flat surface (like a metal baking tray, or traditional salt bed if available). Heat the salt bed to a moderate temperature.
Step-13
Cook the roti:
Step-14
Gently place the shaped roti on a brass plate. Place the plate on the heated salt bed.
Step-15
To ensure even cooking, pierce the roti with a toothpick to allow the heat to penetrate, and optionally, add a few saffron water dots on top for an added flavor and fragrance.
Step-16
Cover it with a lid to trap the heat and bake the roti for 10 to 12 minutes.
Step-17
The roti should bake slowly, with a light golden color but minimal browning.
Step-18
Notes:
Step-19
Ensure that no water but only ghee is used in the preparation of the roti’s dough.
Note:
  • Double the ingredients when cooking for more people to ensure everyone gets a fluffy stack.
  • Swap out eggs for mashed bananas, yogurt, or flaxseed mix if you're vegetarian or allergic to eggs.
  • Use buttermilk instead of regular milk for extra soft and airy pancakes.
  • Let the batter rest for 5-10 minutes before cooking to get fluffier pancakes.
  • Cook on medium-low heat to avoid burning while ensuring even cooking.
  • Add vanilla extract or cinnamon for an extra touch of flavor.
  • Top with fresh fruits, nuts, or honey for a delicious and healthy twist.
seperator
Advertisement

Got a Tasty Tale to Tell?

Whether it’s a secret family recipe, a drool-worthy food adventure, share it with us and get featured on OT Eats.

ALSO EXPLORE

Vector-1